No source given
47% of paper punch cards never get redeemed
The Perkstar article states the figure and cites no source for it. Searches found it only on other loyalty-vendor blogs that repeat it. The published redemption evidence is a field experiment in which 19% of customers given a plain 8-stamp card redeemed it.
Seen on: Perkstar
Circular citation
39% of customers abandon paper loyalty programs because they misplace their cards
Stamp Me attributes the figure to Statista and links to a Loopy Loyalty help page, which also writes "Source: Statista" without a link. No matching Statista record could be found. The nearest paywalled Statista chart is a 2015 survey of 402 US millennials whose top reason was that rewards were not compelling or relevant.
Seen on: Stamp Me
Not on the cited page
53% abandon programs because it takes too long to earn a reward
The figure has been credited to this Stamp Me article, and our own earlier site credited it there too, but 53% does not appear on the page. No primary source for it was found. Published surveys give 49.1% globally and 57% in the UK for rewards taking too long to earn.
Credited to: Stamp Me
Wrong
The average email open rate is less than 2%
MobiLoud shows the email figure in an image, not in the page text. MailerLite's analysis of over 3.6 million campaigns found a median open rate of 43.46% and a click rate of 2.09%, so the figure is close to the click rate, not the open rate. Apple Mail Privacy Protection inflates opens.
Seen on: MobiLoud
Source no longer exists
Push notification click-through rate is 28%
MobiLoud attributes the 28% to a study by the agency Reckless. That study's URL now redirects to the agency's insights index, so the figure cannot be traced to its data. Batch's 2025 benchmark reports contextual push campaigns opened at 14.4% and generic ones at 4.19%.
Seen on: MobiLoud
Not on the cited page
Apple Pay has 580 million+ active users, up ~16% a year
The figure has been credited to this Statista topic page, and our own earlier site credited it there too, but the page contains neither 580 million nor 16%. It says over 500 million people activated the service. Apple publishes no Apple Pay user count. Apple does state an installed base of more than 2.5 billion active devices, and UK Finance publishes mobile-payment registration figures.
Credited to: Statista
Not on the cited page
Google Wallet is available in 50+ countries
The figure has been credited to this ElectroIQ page, and our own earlier site credited it there too, but the page makes no such claim. Google's developer blog says Google Wallet expanded to more than 90 countries and territories in 2024 and has since added 50 more.
Credited to: ElectroIQ
No source given
Acquiring a new customer costs 5 to 25 times more than keeping one
Invesp cites Harvard Business Review. The HBR article gives the range with a hedge ("Depending on which study you believe") and names no study, so no primary source stands behind the figure. It can be quoted only as HBR's hedged range, not as a finding.
Seen on: Invesp
No source given
Wallet pass notifications have a 99% open rate
The Regulr article attributes the 99% to Square's 2025 Loyalty Report. No Square report containing the figure was found, and we found no public, independent benchmark of engagement with Apple or Google Wallet pass notifications.
Seen on: Regulr
No source given
Businesses using digital loyalty see 25-35% higher redemption rates compared to paper cards
The Perkstar article states the range without a source, describes it as outcomes from its own businesses, and gives no data or method. The published redemption evidence found is a field experiment on stamp-card design, not a paper-versus-digital measurement.
Seen on: Perkstar
No source given
Digital loyalty programs increase visit frequency by 30-40%
The Perkstar article states the range without a source and gives no data or method. No primary study with this figure was found.
Seen on: Perkstar
Misquoted
Repeat customers spend 67% more per transaction than first-time customers
The Perkstar article cites no source. The nearest primary finding is Bain and Mainspring's December 1999 survey of 2,116 US online shoppers: in apparel, the average repeat customer spent 67 percent more in months 31 to 36 of the relationship than in months zero to six. That is online apparel in 1999, not spend per transaction.
Seen on: Perkstar
Misquoted
A 5% increase in customer retention correlates with a 25% increase in profit
Queue-it cites Bain. Reichheld's text, hosted by Bain, says an increase in customer retention of 5 percent increases profits by 25 percent to 95 percent, a range from 1990s modelling rather than a correlation or a single 25% figure.
Seen on: Queue-it